|
|
| Author |
Message |
terrydonahue@usa.net science forum beginner
Joined: 07 Oct 2005
Posts: 1
|
Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2005 7:56 pm Post subject:
Seeking Low Cost Improvments to Chapel Acoustics
|
|
|
(Just posted this to alt.audio.pro.live-sound, but thought some folks
here might be able to help...)
Our community has a small chapel (35' long by 20' wide, 12' ceiling)
with the following materials materials:
1) Floor: wood in the sanctuary (10' by 20' at one end) and carpet
(with padding) over concrete everywhere else
2) Walls: Plasterboard on 3 walls, with wood boards on the wall of the
sanctuary.
3) Ceiling: flat drop ceiling with 2' by 2' acoustic ceiling tiles (not
sure exactly what type) - like a standard office ceiling
4) Furniture: wooden pew-like chairs with cushions on the bottom
portion of the seats
The chapel is used by 6-15 people for Mass and communal prayer, a
combination of plainchant and contemporary praise songs, usually with
guitar accompaniment, all unamplified.
Problem:
The room is too "dead", giving little reverberation that makes chant
sound good, and encourages congregational singing. Most of the sound in
the chapel seems to be absorbed by the ceiling and carpet (it was even
worse before we installed the raised wood floor in the sanctuary and
replaced the thick carpet with the current thin one.
Possible Solutions:
I want to find a low-cost solution to improve the acoustics of the
chapel, and therefore have the following questions:
1) If I only have the funds to change the floor OR the ceiling, which
is more important to change first, and to what?
2) Since the simplest improvement I can think of is to just swap the
ceiling tiles, what low-cost ceiling tile is very sound reflective?
In browsing the web, I see Noise Reduction Coefficients (NRCs) listed
for acoustic ceiling tiles that absorb sound well, but haven't found
specific measurements for ones that reflect sound well. Any
links/stores would be appreciated.
Fr. Terry Donahue, CC |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Noral Stewart science forum addict
Joined: 23 May 2005
Posts: 77
|
Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2005 11:44 pm Post subject:
Re: Seeking Low Cost Improvments to Chapel Acoustics
|
|
|
Replace most of the ceiling panels with half-inch gypsum panels. These are
basically wall board cut into 2 by 2 foot squares. You can buy these
already cut for ceilings from USG, National Gypsum, or Celotex Gyptone, or
you can buy larger sheets of wallboard and cut the panels yourself. I
suggest as a first try that leave a ring of one acoustical panel around the
perimeter of the room with all the panels in the center of the room gypsum.
If it is still too dead, replace the rest of the acoustical panels with
gypsum. Leave the carpet and pew cushions as these will keep the room from
getting too lively when it is sparsely occupied.
<terrydonahue@usa.net> wrote in message
news:1128722215.288386.285950@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
| Quote: | (Just posted this to alt.audio.pro.live-sound, but thought some folks
here might be able to help...)
Our community has a small chapel (35' long by 20' wide, 12' ceiling)
with the following materials materials:
1) Floor: wood in the sanctuary (10' by 20' at one end) and carpet
(with padding) over concrete everywhere else
2) Walls: Plasterboard on 3 walls, with wood boards on the wall of the
sanctuary.
3) Ceiling: flat drop ceiling with 2' by 2' acoustic ceiling tiles (not
sure exactly what type) - like a standard office ceiling
4) Furniture: wooden pew-like chairs with cushions on the bottom
portion of the seats
The chapel is used by 6-15 people for Mass and communal prayer, a
combination of plainchant and contemporary praise songs, usually with
guitar accompaniment, all unamplified.
Problem:
The room is too "dead", giving little reverberation that makes chant
sound good, and encourages congregational singing. Most of the sound in
the chapel seems to be absorbed by the ceiling and carpet (it was even
worse before we installed the raised wood floor in the sanctuary and
replaced the thick carpet with the current thin one.
Possible Solutions:
I want to find a low-cost solution to improve the acoustics of the
chapel, and therefore have the following questions:
1) If I only have the funds to change the floor OR the ceiling, which
is more important to change first, and to what?
2) Since the simplest improvement I can think of is to just swap the
ceiling tiles, what low-cost ceiling tile is very sound reflective?
In browsing the web, I see Noise Reduction Coefficients (NRCs) listed
for acoustic ceiling tiles that absorb sound well, but haven't found
specific measurements for ones that reflect sound well. Any
links/stores would be appreciated.
Fr. Terry Donahue, CC
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Angelo Campanella science forum Guru Wannabe
Joined: 08 May 2005
Posts: 226
|
Posted: Sun Oct 09, 2005 2:09 pm Post subject:
Re: Seeking Low Cost Improvments to Chapel Acoustics
|
|
|
terrydonahue@usa.net wrote:
| Quote: | 3) Ceiling: flat drop ceiling with 2' by 2' acoustic ceiling tiles (not
sure exactly what type) - like a standard office ceiling
|
Not the best for communal communication.
| Quote: | The room is too "dead", giving little reverberation that makes chant
sound good, and encourages congregational singing. Most of the sound in
the chapel seems to be absorbed by the ceiling and carpet (it was even
worse before we installed the raised wood floor in the sanctuary and
replaced the thick carpet with the current thin one.
|
ditto
| Quote: | 2) Since the simplest improvement I can think of is to just swap the
ceiling tiles, what low-cost ceiling tile is very sound reflective?
|
Good thinking.
Cut drywall material to the same dimensions as the existing tile so that
the flop into place easily. Paint favored color (flat white?).
[FYI: 1/2" gypsum drywall is cheapest. Larger panels might sag with
time. There, use 5/8" gypsum drywall. It depends on the humidity that
they will encounter in future years. Humid climates make ceiling panels
sag with time.]
Start in the geometric room center, and just forward of center, to
replace existing absorptive tile with these reflective panels. Forward
panels favor lecture format. Central panels favor repartee`.
Conduct services and note speech clarity, music quality and RT improvement.
Continue to add tiles around the perimeter of the beginning bunch.
Migrate forward if anything. Continue to do such expansion until RT get
long (reverberating vowels start to mask succeeding consonants). Halt there.
Also, if HVAC fans and motor sounds are evident, find ways to quiet them.
| Quote: | In browsing the web, I see Noise Reduction Coefficients (NRCs) listed
for acoustic ceiling tiles that absorb sound well, but haven't found
specific measurements for ones that reflect sound well. Any
links/stores would be appreciated.
|
Forget that.
Just cut, paint and install drywall reflector panels as noted.
Enjoy.
Angelo Campanella |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Google
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
The time now is Fri Jan 09, 2009 9:18 pm | All times are GMT
|
|
MPAA | Guitar Lessons | Forums | Mobile Phone | Free Verizon Ringtones
|
|
Copyright © 2004-2005 DeniX Solutions SRL
|
|
Other DeniX Solutions sites:
Electronics forum |
Medicine forum |
Unix/Linux blog |
Unix/Linux documentation |
Unix/Linux forums
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|