Author 
Message 
Christopher Creutzig science forum Guru Wannabe
Joined: 03 May 2005
Posts: 107

Posted: Thu Jul 20, 2006 5:32 pm Post subject:
Re: maxima again...



jimmij wrote:
Quote:  (%i12) ratsimp(sqrt(a*b));
(%o12) sqrt(1  x) sqrt(x + 1)
Where is a problem?

Obviously(?), maxima regards sqrt(1x)*sqrt(x+1) as simpler than
sqrt((1x)*(x+1)). Note that it *did* use your assumptions.
I do not have maxima installed, but I'd guess that with your assumptions,
ratsimp(sqrt(a*b)sqrt(a)*sqrt(b))
will equal zero, which without the assumptions would be wrong, as
Richard pointed out.
Regards,
Christopher 

Back to top 


jimmij science forum beginner
Joined: 17 Jul 2006
Posts: 4

Posted: Thu Jul 20, 2006 12:48 pm Post subject:
Re: maxima again...



"rjf" <fateman@gmail.com> writes:
Quote:  in general, sqrt(a)*sqrt(b) is not equal to sqrt(a*b), so most computer
algebra systems are not going to do this for you by some standard
command.
let a=b=1. Then sqrt(a)*sqrt(b) = i*i = 1.
but sqrt(a*b)=sqrt(1)=1. (at least by convention. really it should be
+/1 but CAS don't usually make that observation). Of course sqrt(1)
is +i, by the same reasoning.

Thanks for explainations.
Lets then assume something:
(%i1) a: 1x;
(%o1) 1  x
(%i2) b: 1+x;
(%o2) x + 1
(%i3) assume(x<1);
(%o3) [x < 1]
(%i4) assume(x>0);
(%o4) [x > 0]
(%i5) sign(x);
(%o5) pos
(%i6) sign(a);
(%o6) pos
(%i7) sign(b);
(%o7) pos
(%i sign(sqrt(a));
(%o pos
(%i9) sign(sqrt(b));
(%i10) a*b;
(%o10) (1  x) (x + 1)
(%i11) ratsimp(a*b);
2
(%o11) 1  x
(%i12) ratsimp(sqrt(a*b));
(%o12) sqrt(1  x) sqrt(x + 1)
Where is a problem?

jimmij 

Back to top 


rjf science forum beginner
Joined: 05 May 2006
Posts: 5

Posted: Thu Jul 20, 2006 6:22 am Post subject:
Re: maxima again...



in general, sqrt(a)*sqrt(b) is not equal to sqrt(a*b), so most computer
algebra systems are not going to do this for you by some standard
command.
let a=b=1. Then sqrt(a)*sqrt(b) = i*i = 1.
but sqrt(a*b)=sqrt(1)=1. (at least by convention. really it should be
+/1 but CAS don't usually make that observation). Of course sqrt(1)
is +i, by the same reasoning.
radcan can do some related simplifications, and you can also see
describe(denest);
jimmij wrote:
Quote:  (%i1) a: sqrt(1x);
(%o1) sqrt(1  x)
(%i2) b: sqrt(1+x);
(%o2) sqrt(x + 1)
(%i3) a*b;
(%o3) sqrt(1  x) sqrt(x + 1)
How can I simpify this to sqrt(1x^2)?
I tried ratsimp, trigsimp, expand, ratexpand, trigexpand...
Nothing works.

jimmij 


Back to top 


jimmij science forum beginner
Joined: 17 Jul 2006
Posts: 4

Posted: Wed Jul 19, 2006 5:28 pm Post subject:
maxima again...



(%i1) a: sqrt(1x);
(%o1) sqrt(1  x)
(%i2) b: sqrt(1+x);
(%o2) sqrt(x + 1)
(%i3) a*b;
(%o3) sqrt(1  x) sqrt(x + 1)
How can I simpify this to sqrt(1x^2)?
I tried ratsimp, trigsimp, expand, ratexpand, trigexpand...
Nothing works.

jimmij 

Back to top 


Google


Back to top 



The time now is Sun Sep 24, 2017 2:10 pm  All times are GMT

