Search   Memberlist   Usergroups
 Page 2 of 2 [22 Posts] View previous topic :: View next topic Goto page:  Previous  1, 2
Author Message
Mickey
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 14

Posted: Thu May 19, 2005 5:15 pm    Post subject: Re: thanks to all

correction, I meant in solving for d :)

Mickey wrote:
 Quote: I had noticed the player - dexterity swap error and also the error I had in the calculation for c. I now see where I went wrong in calculating b, forget to multiply by 10. Thanks very much Bill, your breakdown of everything made it clear. Thanks to everyone who replied. -Mickey Bill McCray wrote: On Thu, 19 May 2005 11:11:47 -0400, Mickey REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote: Bill, I tried the following, but my results are skewed by -5. Where did I go wrong? If the monster type is equal to 1 and the player dexterity is equal to 10, then the monster has a 50% chance of striking the player. If the monster type is equal to 28 and the player dexterity is equal to 10, then the monster has a 100% chance of striking the player. If the monster type is equal to 1 and the player dexterity is equal to 100, then the monster has a 0% chance of striking the player. If the monster type is equal to 28 and the player dexterity is equal to 100, then the monster has a 50% chance of striking the player. aP + bM + cPM + d First thing is that you've put the player's dexterity in the monster variable and the monster type in the player's variable, so let's change the formula to aM + bP + cPM + d to match what you have below. a + 10b + 10c + d = 50 28a + 10b + 280c + d = 100 a + 100b + 100c + d = 0 28a + 100b + 2800c + d = 50 27a + 270c = 50 27a + 2600c = 50 2330c = 0 c = 0 27a = 50 a = 50/27 Okay so far. 50/27 + 10b + d = 50 50/27 + 100b + d = 0 -90b = 50 b = -5/9 50/27 - 15/27 + d = 50 Here you should be substituting a and b into a + 10b + d = 50 which you give you 50/27 - 150/27 + d = 50 Solving this for d gives d - 100/27 = 50 d = 50 + 100/27 d = (1350 + 100)/27 d = 1450/27 35/27 + d = 50 d = 1350/27 - 35/27 d = 1315/27 (50/27)P - (15/27)M + 1315/27 = (50P - 15M + 1315)/27 = (50M - 15P + 1450)/27 -Mickey Bill Swap first and last parts of username and ISP for address.
Mickey
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 14

 Posted: Mon May 23, 2005 9:02 pm    Post subject: Game formulas Bill, I need something more flexible than your previous solution. I need to be able to tweak the game play by changing the percentages. Something more along the lines of the following. I welcome everyones input. Given a monster type range, a player dexterity range and four percentages A,B,C,D. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100 chance of striking the player. -Mickey
Bill McCray
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 44

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 12:02 am    Post subject: Re: Game formulas

On Mon, 23 May 2005 19:02:54 -0400, Mickey
<REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote:

 Quote: Bill, I need something more flexible than your previous solution. I need to be able to tweak the game play by changing the percentages. Something more along the lines of the following. I welcome everyones input. Given a monster type range, a player dexterity range and four percentages A,B,C,D. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100 chance of striking the player. -Mickey

aP + bM + cPM + d

a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100
a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100
a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100
a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100

Solve for a, b, c, and d.

Bill

Mickey
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 14

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 4:37 pm    Post subject: Re: Game formulas

Bill,

The problem I have is that every time I want to tweak the results I have
to solve for a, b, c, d, which with my math skills, takes a while. Is it
possible to derive a single formula where I can input the dexterity,
monster index and attributes to compute the result? It may not be
possible, but I though I would ask. I spent all day yesterday solving
for a,b,c,d for one result! I am currently having great difficulty
solving for a, b, c, d for the following attributes:

m=1, p=10, result=25
m=1, p=100, result=0
m=28, p=10, result=100
m=28, p=100, result=50

Thank you.

-Mickey

Bill McCray wrote:
 Quote: On Mon, 23 May 2005 19:02:54 -0400, Mickey REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote: Bill, I need something more flexible than your previous solution. I need to be able to tweak the game play by changing the percentages. Something more along the lines of the following. I welcome everyones input. Given a monster type range, a player dexterity range and four percentages A,B,C,D. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100 chance of striking the player. -Mickey aP + bM + cPM + d a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100 a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100 a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100 a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100 Solve for a, b, c, and d. Bill Swap first and last parts of username and ISP for address.
Bill McCray
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 44

Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 9:22 pm    Post subject: Re: Game formulas

On Tue, 24 May 2005 14:37:02 -0400, Mickey
<REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote:

 Quote: Bill McCray wrote: On Mon, 23 May 2005 19:02:54 -0400, Mickey REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote: Bill, I need something more flexible than your previous solution. I need to be able to tweak the game play by changing the percentages. Something more along the lines of the following. I welcome everyones input. Given a monster type range, a player dexterity range and four percentages A,B,C,D. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100 chance of striking the player. -Mickey aP + bM + cPM + d a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100 a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100 a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100 a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100 Solve for a, b, c, and d. Bill Bill, The problem I have is that every time I want to tweak the results I have to solve for a, b, c, d, which with my math skills, takes a while. Is it possible to derive a single formula where I can input the dexterity, monster index and attributes to compute the result? It may not be possible, but I though I would ask. I spent all day yesterday solving for a,b,c,d for one result! I am currently having great difficulty solving for a, b, c, d for the following attributes: m=1, p=10, result=25 m=1, p=100, result=0 m=28, p=10, result=100 m=28, p=100, result=50 Thank you. -Mickey

Yeah. As I said above, just solve the four equations for a, b, c, and
d.

It's one of the powers of algebra that you can solve the four
equations once for all sets of values you might want to substitute for
the variables. Rather than substitute for the variables and then
solve the equations, solve the equations before you substitute for the
variables.

1: a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100
2: a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100
3: a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100
4: a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100

[#2 - #1]
5: b(Mmax - Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = (B - A)/100
[#4 - #3]
6: b(Mmax - Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C)/100

[#6 - #5]
7: c(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C - B + A)/100

[solve 7 for c]
8: c = (D - C - B + A)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)

Let's name the denominator E

E = 100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)

so c = (D - C - B + A)/E

[substitute for c in 6 and solve for b]
9: b(Mmax - Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C)/100

b(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C)/100 - c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin)

100b(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C) - 100c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin)

100b(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C) - 100(D - C - B + A)(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin)/E

b = (D - C)/100(Mmax - Mmin) - (D - C - B + A)(Pmax)/E

b = (D - C)(Pmax - Pmin)/E - (D - C - B + A)(Pmax)/E

b = [(D - C)(Pmax - Pmin) - (D - C - B + A)(Pmax)]/E

b = [(D - C)(Pmax - Pmin) - (D - C)(Pmax) + (B - A)(Pmax)]/E

b = [(D - C)(- Pmin) + (B - A)(Pmax)]/E

b = [(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E

[#3 - #1]
10: a(Pmax - Pmin) + c(Mmin)(Pmax - Pmin) = (C - A)/100

[Substitute for c in 10 and solve for a]
10: a(Pmax - Pmin) = (C - A)/100 - c(Mmin)(Pmax - Pmin)

a = (C - A)/100(Pmax - Pmin) - c(Mmin)

a = (C - A)(Mmax - Mmin)/E - (D - C - B + A)(Mmin)/E

a = [(C - A)(Mmax - Mmin) - (D - C - B + A)(Mmin)]/E

a = [(C - A)(Mmax - Mmin) - (D - B)(Mmin) + (C - A)(Mmin)]/E

a = [(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E

[Substitute for a, b, and c in #1, solve for d]

d = A/100 - a(Pmin) - b(Mmin) - c(Pmin)(Mmin)

d = A(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/E
- (Pmin)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E
- (Mmin)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E
- (Pmin)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A)/E

dE = A[(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]
- (C - A)(Pmin)(Mmax) + (D - B)(Pmin)(Mmin)
- (B - A)(Pmax)(Mmin) + (D - C)(Pmin)(Mmin)
- (Pmin)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A)

dE = A[(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)
+ (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin)] +
B[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)] +
C[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)] +
D[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin)]

dE = A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)

d = [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E

So assuming I haven't made any mistakes (unlikely, of course):

E = 100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)
a = [(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E
b = [(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E
c = (D - C - B + A)/E
d = [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E

To test the result, substitute back into the four original equations:

1:

Does a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100?

a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d
=
(Pmin)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E +
(Mmin)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E +
(Pmin)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A)/E +
[A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E
=
{A[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Mmin)(Pmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] +
B[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Mmin)(Pmax) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] +
C[(Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] +
D[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
{A[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Mmin)(Pmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] +
B[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Mmin)(Pmax) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] +
C[(Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] +
D[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
A(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/E
=
A(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)
=
A/100

Yes, it does.

2:

Does a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100

a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d
=
(Pmin)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E +
(Mmax)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E +
(Pmin)(Mmax)(D - C - B + A)/E +
[A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E
=
{A[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] +
B[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] +
C[(Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] +
D[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
B[(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]/E
=
B(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)
=
B/100

Yes, this does, too. WOW!

3:
Does a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100?

a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d
=
{(Pmax)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)] +
(Mmin)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)] +
(Pmax)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A) +
[A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
{A[-(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] +
B[(Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] +
C[(Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] +
D[-(Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
C[(Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)]/E
=
C(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)
=
C/100

Three for three. I'm amazed.

4:

Does a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100?

a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d
=
{(Pmax)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)] +
(Mmax)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)] +
(Pmax)(Mmax)(D - C - B + A) +
[A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
{A[-(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] +
B[(Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] +
C[(Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] +
D[-(Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E
=
D(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)
=
D/100

Whoopie! It checks out.

So the result is:

E = 100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)
a = [(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E
b = [(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E
c = (D - C - B + A)/E
d = [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E

Note that Pmax cannot equal Pmin and Mmax cannot equal Mmin.

How much was it that you offered for the solution?

Bill

Mickey
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 14

Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 11:42 am    Post subject: Re: Game formulas

Bill,

Wow, that was some post, thank you. Looking back now I should have
specified the problem more like this:

Given a monster type range and player dexterity range and using one
index from each range with four percentages A,B,C,D:

If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player
dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100
chance of striking the player.

If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player
dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100
chance of striking the player.

If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player
dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100
chance of striking the player.

If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player
dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100
chance of striking the player.

Ultimately in my program I can only input the player dexterity and the
monster type to find the percentage of striking the player. Your posted
solution is using the ranges and not specific values and that of course
was the fault of my previous post. You must be a math professor, your
posts have been clear and very well written. Thank you.

-Mickey

Bill McCray wrote:
 Quote: On Tue, 24 May 2005 14:37:02 -0400, Mickey REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote: Bill McCray wrote: On Mon, 23 May 2005 19:02:54 -0400, Mickey REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote: Bill, I need something more flexible than your previous solution. I need to be able to tweak the game play by changing the percentages. Something more along the lines of the following. I welcome everyones input. Given a monster type range, a player dexterity range and four percentages A,B,C,D. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100 chance of striking the player. -Mickey aP + bM + cPM + d a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100 a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100 a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100 a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100 Solve for a, b, c, and d. Bill Bill, The problem I have is that every time I want to tweak the results I have to solve for a, b, c, d, which with my math skills, takes a while. Is it possible to derive a single formula where I can input the dexterity, monster index and attributes to compute the result? It may not be possible, but I though I would ask. I spent all day yesterday solving for a,b,c,d for one result! I am currently having great difficulty solving for a, b, c, d for the following attributes: m=1, p=10, result=25 m=1, p=100, result=0 m=28, p=10, result=100 m=28, p=100, result=50 Thank you. -Mickey Yeah. As I said above, just solve the four equations for a, b, c, and d. It's one of the powers of algebra that you can solve the four equations once for all sets of values you might want to substitute for the variables. Rather than substitute for the variables and then solve the equations, solve the equations before you substitute for the variables. 1: a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100 2: a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100 3: a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100 4: a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100 [#2 - #1] 5: b(Mmax - Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = (B - A)/100 [#4 - #3] 6: b(Mmax - Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C)/100 [#6 - #5] 7: c(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C - B + A)/100 [solve 7 for c] 8: c = (D - C - B + A)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) Let's name the denominator E E = 100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) so c = (D - C - B + A)/E [substitute for c in 6 and solve for b] 9: b(Mmax - Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C)/100 b(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C)/100 - c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin) 100b(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C) - 100c(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin) 100b(Mmax - Mmin) = (D - C) - 100(D - C - B + A)(Pmax)(Mmax - Mmin)/E b = (D - C)/100(Mmax - Mmin) - (D - C - B + A)(Pmax)/E b = (D - C)(Pmax - Pmin)/E - (D - C - B + A)(Pmax)/E b = [(D - C)(Pmax - Pmin) - (D - C - B + A)(Pmax)]/E b = [(D - C)(Pmax - Pmin) - (D - C)(Pmax) + (B - A)(Pmax)]/E b = [(D - C)(- Pmin) + (B - A)(Pmax)]/E b = [(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E [#3 - #1] 10: a(Pmax - Pmin) + c(Mmin)(Pmax - Pmin) = (C - A)/100 [Substitute for c in 10 and solve for a] 10: a(Pmax - Pmin) = (C - A)/100 - c(Mmin)(Pmax - Pmin) a = (C - A)/100(Pmax - Pmin) - c(Mmin) a = (C - A)(Mmax - Mmin)/E - (D - C - B + A)(Mmin)/E a = [(C - A)(Mmax - Mmin) - (D - C - B + A)(Mmin)]/E a = [(C - A)(Mmax - Mmin) - (D - B)(Mmin) + (C - A)(Mmin)]/E a = [(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E [Substitute for a, b, and c in #1, solve for d] d = A/100 - a(Pmin) - b(Mmin) - c(Pmin)(Mmin) d = A(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/E - (Pmin)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E - (Mmin)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E - (Pmin)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A)/E dE = A[(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)] - (C - A)(Pmin)(Mmax) + (D - B)(Pmin)(Mmin) - (B - A)(Pmax)(Mmin) + (D - C)(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A) dE = A[(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin)] + B[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)] + C[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)] + D[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin)] dE = A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin) d = [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E So assuming I haven't made any mistakes (unlikely, of course): E = 100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) a = [(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E b = [(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E c = (D - C - B + A)/E d = [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E To test the result, substitute back into the four original equations: 1: Does a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = A/100? a(Pmin) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmin)(Mmin) + d = (Pmin)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E + (Mmin)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E + (Pmin)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A)/E + [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E = {A[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Mmin)(Pmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] + B[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Mmin)(Pmax) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] + C[(Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] + D[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = {A[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Mmin)(Pmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] + B[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Mmin)(Pmax) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] + C[(Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] + D[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = A(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/E = A(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = A/100 Yes, it does. 2: Does a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = B/100 a(Pmin) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmin)(Mmax) + d = (Pmin)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E + (Mmax)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E + (Pmin)(Mmax)(D - C - B + A)/E + [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E = {A[-(Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] + B[(Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] + C[(Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] + D[-(Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = B[(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]/E = B(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = B/100 Yes, this does, too. WOW! 3: Does a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = C/100? a(Pmax) + b(Mmin) + c(Pmax)(Mmin) + d = {(Pmax)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)] + (Mmin)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)] + (Pmax)(Mmin)(D - C - B + A) + [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = {A[-(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] + B[(Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] + C[(Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] + D[-(Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = C[(Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin) - (Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax)]/E = C(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = C/100 Three for three. I'm amazed. 4: Does a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = D/100? a(Pmax) + b(Mmax) + c(Pmax)(Mmax) + d = {(Pmax)[(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)] + (Mmax)[(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)] + (Pmax)(Mmax)(D - C - B + A) + [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = {A[-(Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax)] + B[(Pmax)(Mmin) + (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmin)] + C[(Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmax) - (Pmax)(Mmax) - (Pmin)(Mmax)] + D[-(Pmax)(Mmin) - (Pmin)(Mmax) + (Pmax)(Mmax) + (Pmin)(Mmin)]}/E = D(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin)/100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) = D/100 Whoopie! It checks out. So the result is: E = 100(Pmax - Pmin)(Mmax - Mmin) a = [(C - A)(Mmax) - (D - B)(Mmin)]/E b = [(B - A)(Pmax) - (D - C)(Pmin)]/E c = (D - C - B + A)/E d = [A(Pmax)(Mmax) - B(Pmax)(Mmin) - C(Pmin)(Mmax) + D(Pmin)(Mmin)]/E Note that Pmax cannot equal Pmin and Mmax cannot equal Mmin. How much was it that you offered for the solution? Bill Swap first and last parts of username and ISP for address.
Bill McCray
science forum beginner

Joined: 18 May 2005
Posts: 44

Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 8:01 pm    Post subject: Re: Game formulas

On Wed, 25 May 2005 09:42:31 -0400, Mickey
<REMOVETHISTEXT.portillas@hotmail.com> wrote:

 Quote: Bill, Wow, that was some post, thank you. Looking back now I should have specified the problem more like this: Given a monster type range and player dexterity range and using one index from each range with four percentages A,B,C,D: If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has A/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the minimum, then the monster has B/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the minimum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has C/100 chance of striking the player. If the monster type index is equal to the maximum and the player dexterity index is equal to the maximum, then the monster has D/100 chance of striking the player. Ultimately in my program I can only input the player dexterity and the monster type to find the percentage of striking the player. Your posted solution is using the ranges and not specific values and that of course was the fault of my previous post.

I don't think you have asked for anything here that is different from
your previous post. Take whatever four specific values you want your
dexterity formula to match, substitute in the formulas I derived in my
last post, and compute a, b, c, and d. Your dexterity formula is than

aP + bM + cPM + d

This resulting formula will match your four specified conditions
exactly and will give dexterity values for points between those four
specified condition that vary linear with P for a fixed M and vary
linearly with M for a fixed P.

In case you didn't understand, Pmax and Pmin are the maximum and
minimum values for the P range (respectively) and Mmax and Mmin are
the maximum and minimum values for the M range (respectively).

 Quote: You must be a math professor, your posts have been clear and very well written. Thank you.

And thank you for that comment. No, I'm not a math professor. I'm an
electrical engineer by schooling and a logic designer and programmer
by experience. I did well in my math classes in school and have
always enjoyed the subject, which is why I follow this newsgroup.
However, I admit that there are a lot of posts here that are well over

I try to tailor my writing to my perception of the experience level of
my audience, preferring to err on the side of giving too much detail
rather than not enough.

As for the "well written", I decided somewhere in my public-school
years that, since English is my only native language, I should try to
learn to use it properly. For example, I have formulate Bill's Rule
of Homophones: Just because two words sound alike when spoken does
not make them acceptable substitutes for each other in writing. I
know the difference between "its" and "it's", and I try to be careful
to use the correct one in each instance. I'm not perfect (oh, the
shame), but I do try. Also, I proofread each post I write, sometimes
more than once, before sending it off.

I call myself a "programmar programmer".

Bill

 Display posts from previous: All Posts1 Day7 Days2 Weeks1 Month3 Months6 Months1 Year Oldest FirstNewest First
 Page 2 of 2 [22 Posts] Goto page:  Previous  1, 2 View previous topic :: View next topic
 The time now is Tue Dec 11, 2018 6:22 am | All times are GMT
 Jump to: Select a forum-------------------Forum index|___Science and Technology    |___Math    |   |___Research    |   |___num-analysis    |   |___Symbolic    |   |___Combinatorics    |   |___Probability    |   |   |___Prediction    |   |       |   |___Undergraduate    |   |___Recreational    |       |___Physics    |   |___Research    |   |___New Theories    |   |___Acoustics    |   |___Electromagnetics    |   |___Strings    |   |___Particle    |   |___Fusion    |   |___Relativity    |       |___Chem    |   |___Analytical    |   |___Electrochem    |   |   |___Battery    |   |       |   |___Coatings    |       |___Engineering        |___Control        |___Mechanics        |___Chemical