Author 
Message 
Oh No science forum addict
Joined: 06 Apr 2006
Posts: 82

Posted: Mon Jul 10, 2006 3:55 am Post subject:
Question about the path of a particle in Schwarzschild region of an cosmos



As I understand it we can think of the Schwarzschild geometry
surrounding an isolated star as a static perturbation within an
expanding flat or near flat spacetime. I would much appreciate
correction if I am wrong.
We can model elliptical orbits with a Newtonian approximation at
moderate distances from the star, and in this case expansion has no
meaning beyond a change of coordinates. That seems fine.
But if we model a hyperbolic orbit then at some point the gravity of the
star becomes irrelevant, and the orbiting body moves into deep space, so
that Hubble expansion must become the dominant part of its motion. My
question is, How do we model such an orbit and where may I better study
it?
Regards

Charles Francis
substitute charles for NotI to email 

Back to top 


Henning Makholm science forum beginner
Joined: 19 Mar 2006
Posts: 7

Posted: Mon Jul 10, 2006 3:41 pm Post subject:
Re: Question about the path of a particle in Schwarzschild region of an cosmos



Scripsit Oh No <NotI@charlesfrancis.wanadoo.co.uk>
Quote:  As I understand it we can think of the Schwarzschild geometry
surrounding an isolated star as a static perturbation within an
expanding flat or near flat spacetime.

...
Quote:  But if we model a hyperbolic orbit then at some point the gravity of the
star becomes irrelevant, and the orbiting body moves into deep space, so
that Hubble expansion must become the dominant part of its motion. My
question is, How do we model such an orbit and where may I better study
it?

The Schwarzschild metric does not include any Hubble expansion.
If you want to include that, you need to switch to a more realistic
cosmological model than "isolated star in an otherwise empty
universe". Which implies that you have to provide some positive
average matter density in the outer universe.

Henning Makholm "I can get fat! I can sing!" 

Back to top 


Oh No science forum addict
Joined: 06 Apr 2006
Posts: 82

Posted: Tue Jul 11, 2006 4:35 pm Post subject:
Re: Question about the path of a particle in Schwarzschild region of an cosmos



Thus spake Henning Makholm <henning@makholm.net>
Quote:  Scripsit Oh No <NotI@charlesfrancis.wanadoo.co.uk
As I understand it we can think of the Schwarzschild geometry
surrounding an isolated star as a static perturbation within an
expanding flat or near flat spacetime.
..
But if we model a hyperbolic orbit then at some point the gravity of the
star becomes irrelevant, and the orbiting body moves into deep space, so
that Hubble expansion must become the dominant part of its motion. My
question is, How do we model such an orbit and where may I better study
it?
The Schwarzschild metric does not include any Hubble expansion.
If you want to include that, you need to switch to a more realistic
cosmological model than "isolated star in an otherwise empty
universe". Which implies that you have to provide some positive
average matter density in the outer universe.
Well, yes. That is the reason for my question. Unless I have overlooked 
it, such a model is not given in any of my text books. The example I
gave was merely the simplest instance of such a model I could think of,
since it is perfectly possible to describe an empty flat expanding toy
universe. Just not one that obeys Friedman's equation.
Regards

Charles Francis
substitute charles for NotI to email 

Back to top 


mark_horn@sbcglobal.net science forum beginner
Joined: 18 Dec 2005
Posts: 6

Posted: Tue Jul 11, 2006 4:35 pm Post subject:
Re: Question about the path of a particle in Schwarzschild region of an cosmos



Oh No wrote:
Quote:  But if we model a hyperbolic orbit then at some point the gravity of the
star becomes irrelevant, and the orbiting body moves into deep space, so
that Hubble expansion must become the dominant part of its motion. My
question is, How do we model such an orbit and where may I better study
it?

I believe that, at the distances where the Hubble expansion becomes
significant, a solar system is (presumably) still bound within a
galaxy, so the expansion velocity is always irrelevant, wrt to your
orbiting mass. Beyond that I think you need to consider things like
largescale bulk flow of whole galaxies in the streaming motion of
clusters; the CMB dipole anisotropy etc. (see e.g. Lauer and Portman,
APJ 425:418438, 1994 April and Hudson et al APJ 512:7082, 1999).
Cheers,
mark jonathan horn 

Back to top 


Greg Egan science forum addict
Joined: 01 May 2005
Posts: 75

Posted: Thu Jul 13, 2006 12:10 am Post subject:
Re: Question about the path of a particle in Schwarzschild region of an cosmos



Oh No wrote:
Quote:  As I understand it we can think of the Schwarzschild geometry
surrounding an isolated star as a static perturbation within an
expanding flat or near flat spacetime. I would much appreciate
correction if I am wrong.
We can model elliptical orbits with a Newtonian approximation at
moderate distances from the star, and in this case expansion has no
meaning beyond a change of coordinates. That seems fine.
But if we model a hyperbolic orbit then at some point the gravity of the
star becomes irrelevant, and the orbiting body moves into deep space, so
that Hubble expansion must become the dominant part of its motion. My
question is, How do we model such an orbit and where may I better study
it?

How about studying the Schwarzschildde Sitter solution, which is an
exact vacuum solution where the expansion is due to a cosmological
constant?
I'm afraid I personally know nothing about this solution, but I expect
people have worked it all out in great detail. 

Back to top 


Oh No science forum addict
Joined: 06 Apr 2006
Posts: 82

Posted: Thu Jul 13, 2006 12:39 pm Post subject:
Re: Question about the path of a particle in Schwarzschild region of an cosmos



Thus spake Greg Egan <gregegan@netspace.net.au>
Quote:  Oh No wrote:
As I understand it we can think of the Schwarzschild geometry
surrounding an isolated star as a static perturbation within an
expanding flat or near flat spacetime. I would much appreciate
correction if I am wrong.
We can model elliptical orbits with a Newtonian approximation at
moderate distances from the star, and in this case expansion has no
meaning beyond a change of coordinates. That seems fine.
But if we model a hyperbolic orbit then at some point the gravity of the
star becomes irrelevant, and the orbiting body moves into deep space, so
that Hubble expansion must become the dominant part of its motion. My
question is, How do we model such an orbit and where may I better study
it?
How about studying the Schwarzschildde Sitter solution, which is an
exact vacuum solution where the expansion is due to a cosmological
constant?

Thanks. That does not seem like a bad starting point.
Quote: 
I'm afraid I personally know nothing about this solution, but I expect
people have worked it all out in great detail.
Yes, a quick glance at recent literature shows it has attracted 
attention since the advent of the concordance cosmology, though I will
need to start with papers written about 1918 I think.
Regards

Charles Francis
substitute charles for NotI to email 

Back to top 


Google


Back to top 



The time now is Thu Sep 21, 2017 11:09 pm  All times are GMT

